| AmateurAmateur is one of the five standard difficulties. It pays 1x rewards, is open from the start, gives 3 evidence types and starts with 5 minutes of setup time and 100% sanity. | Standard difficulty | 1x | 1 | 100% | 100% |
| IntermediateIntermediate is one of the five standard difficulties. It pays 2x rewards, unlocks at level 10, gives 3 evidence types and starts with 2 minutes of setup time and 100% sanity. | Standard difficulty | 2x | 10 | 100% | 150% |
| ProfessionalProfessional is one of the five standard difficulties. It pays 3x rewards, unlocks at level 20, gives 3 evidence types and starts with no setup time and 100% sanity. | Standard difficulty | 3x | 20 | 100% | 200% |
| NightmareNightmare is one of the five standard difficulties. It pays 4x rewards, unlocks at level 30, gives 2 evidence types and starts with no setup time and 100% sanity. | Standard difficulty | 4x | 30 | 100% | 200% |
| InsanityInsanity is one of the five standard difficulties. It pays 6x rewards, unlocks at level 40, gives 1 evidence types and starts with no setup time and 75% sanity. | Standard difficulty | 6x | 40 | 75% | 200% |